
Physicist Richard Feynman
once said, “Religion is a
culture of faith. Science is
a culture of doubt.” Can
the two ever connect in the
physician’s office?
Let’s just start with the cold, hard facts.
Studies suggest that up to 77 percent of
patients would like spiritual issues considered
as part of their medical care, yet only 10
percent to 20 percent of physicians discuss
these ideas with patients.
In a landmark 2007 Harvard University
study, some 72 percent of patients said that
their spiritual needs were minimally or not
at all met by the medical system. Yet, this
variable – the degree of spiritual support –
was the second most powerful predictor of
quality of life.
Do you hear that line between faith and
science beginning to blur? Regardless of what
you think about the efficacy of faith as part of
the healing process, there is a growing body
of evidence pointing to the clear need for
physicians to be able to better connect mind,
body and spirit.
SURVEY SHOWS
There are a plethora of studies supporting
the idea that spirituality and faith can be
beneficial in the healing process. Faith has
been connected to longer life, a more positive
outlook, strong social support networks,
less depression and enhanced recovery from
illness and surgery.
At the very least, an individual’s faith
has an impact on his or her experience of
illness and disease. Placebo effect? Perhaps
so. But positive beliefs, higher expectations
and strong relationships all work together
to improve health outcomes and should be
considered relevant in the provision of health
care.
Conversation about and an understanding
of a patient’s spirituality can be valuable to
the physician, as well. Faith may well provide
a context for a patient’s understanding of
the illness and may affect the type of care
a person is willing to seek and accept. This
information can help the physician guide the
way in which care is suggested or provided. It
might also lead to better following of doctor’s
orders. One study showed that a physician’s
inquiry about spiritual beliefs strengthens a
patient’s trust in the physician.
HOW TO BEGIN?
The clinical integration of faith is not
about indoctrination in a physician’s own
personal faith. It is about asking questions
and incorporating a patient’s unique take on
spirituality, helping him or her apply it to the
healing process.
There are several ways in which physicians
can begin this process, regardless of their
own personal relationship with faith, religion
and spirituality. Two, in particular, stand
out from the crowd because they are easy to
implement and easy to remember.
The first is HOPE, developed by a pair of
physicians from Brown University School of
Medicine.
Questions for the patient follow this
structure:
H: Hope
What are the sources of hope, meaning,
comfort, strength, peace, love and
connection for the patient?
O: Organized religion
Is the patient involved in organized
religion? Which?
P: Personal practices
What is the patient’s personal spirituality
and practices?
E: Effect on care
What effects does the patient’s
spirituality have on his or her view of
medical care and end of life issues?
Another practical tool is FICA. No, not
payroll taxes. This is an assessment developed
by Christina Pulchalski, M.D., a professor of
medicine at George Washington University
Medical Center.
It stands for:
F: Faith
What gives meaning to the patient’s life?
I: Importance and Influence:
How important is faith to the patient?
C: Community:
Is the patient part of a religious or
spiritual community?
A: Address in care:
How would the patient like you to
address these issues in providing health
care?
Based on the answers to these questions,
a physician will have a clearer idea of how
spirituality and faith might play out in
health care and healing. It may take all of 2
minutes – but it may help determine how
best to respond, whether it’s referring to
another doctor or chaplain, discussing patient
expectations for healing or even clarifying
whether or not the patient wants the
physician to talk about spiritual issues.
We are finally in a place where there’s a
growing interest in honoring the connection
between the healing arts and faith – or at
least in taking the conversation deeper.
Paul Parks, D.Min. is executive director for San
Antonio’s Ecumenical Center for Religion and
Health, a nonprofit counseling and education
center. For more information about upcoming
seminars and workshops offering CEU credits, visit
www.ecrh.org.